HUSCAP logo Hokkaido Univ. logo

Hokkaido University Collection of Scholarly and Academic Papers >
文学研究科  >
応用倫理 >
第9号 >


9_02akiba.pdf1.03 MBPDF見る/開く

タイトル: 自己抹消的な道徳理論の問題点は(あるとすれば)何か
その他のタイトル: What are the Problems( if any) of Self-Effacing Moral Theories?
著者: 秋葉, 剛史 著作を一覧する
発行日: 2016年 3月31日
出版者: 北海道大学大学院文学研究科応用倫理研究教育センター
誌名: 応用倫理
巻: 9
開始ページ: 12
終了ページ: 29
抄録: Moral theories generally tell us the right course of action. They deliver practical advices (or a series of commands) about how we should act, so it seems natural for those who sincerely accept a given moral theory to try to figure out, in each case where some practical decision is needed, what the theory recommends, and act accordingly. However, this is not what a moral theory always tells us to do. Certain moral theories in fact tell their followers not to consult them in daily decision-making. The reason for this is simply that if we consciously intend to act as the theories recommend, it would become difficult or even impossible for us to act in that manner. In recent literature, moral theories that satisfy this condition are called selfeffacing, and have attracted some attention. Although quite a few authors seem to endorse the view that this character of self-effacement makes a moral theory highly problematic (or even unacceptable), in this paper I shall argue that this view is ungrounded. To do this, I will critically examine various objections to self-effacing moral theories found in the literature that concern the following points, respectively: lack of action-guidingness; threat of undermining psychological harmony and the desirable form of moral deliberation; an absurd requirement to have mutually contradicting beliefs; and an invitation to a kind of self-deception. It will be argued that none of these objections constitutes a serious threat to self-effacing moral theories as such.
資料タイプ: bulletin (article)


本サイトに関するご意見・お問い合わせは repo at へお願いします。 - 北海道大学